Sunday, July 21, 2019
Matzaââ¬â¢s (1964) Delinquency and Drift
Matzaââ¬â¢s (1964) Delinquency and Drift David Matzaââ¬â¢s work is often is said to have offered a necessary counteraction to the postulates of the subcultural theory (Young: 1974). In 1957 David Matza and Gersham Sykes presented a radically new theory of deviant behaviour in their seminal work entitled, Techniques of Neutralisation: A Theory of Delinquency and again collaborated in 1961. The dialogue was significantly extended by Matza in his subsequent works, Delinquency and Drift (1964) and Becoming Deviant (1969). This paper will provide a description and evaluation of Matzaââ¬â¢s theories. It will then proffer a brief discussion on why Matzaââ¬â¢s writings on crime presents a shift from traditional subcultural theories. Matzaââ¬â¢s work shows a rethink about deviants and how they process and rationalize their crime. He questions the notion that deviants are inherently opposed to societal norms and codes of conduct, and that their actions signify a rejection of the rule of law. He maintains that delinquent values do not necessarily follow a consistent continuum, and therefore to say that delinquency and deviants reject the rule of law is erroneous. He uses the examples of teenage delinquents to demonstrate that while many teenagers commit delinquent acts, many do not offend within a delinquent space or a delinquent subculture. He argues that many times they can immediately return to continuous actions which demonstrate affinity with ââ¬Å"normalcyâ⬠. In these instances, Matza argues that instead of being in opposition to the rule of law, some acts of delinquency represent a loosening or distance from more positively favoured and consensus value systems to an adoption of what he terms ââ¬Å" subterraneanâ⬠values. Matza and Sykes (1961) differentiated between subterranean values and formal or mainstream values to highlight this point. Matza identifies formal values as those which demonstrate deferred gratification, can be predictable, respect bureaucratic processes, not aggressive, and conforms to the normal routine. They also have an introspective characteristic which refrains from euphoria, plans meticulously, shows reservation and restraint, and is non-impulsive. Conversely, subterranean values are identified as: relishing short term hedonism and excitement, always seeking change and alternatives, impulsive, very sociable and carefree, and is not afraid to display to aggression. Within this framework, Matza defends his argument by stating that deviants who accept subterranean values usually accentuate these characteristics for short term personal gains, or during leisure periods. Taylor et al (1973) suggests that Matzaââ¬â¢s work (1964) represents an attempt to avoid distorting the motivations of the delinquent and to present a naturalistic analysis of deviant behaviour. Matza contends that theories which strive to label some deviants and establish sub-cultures of deviance, overstate the levels of delinquency and are a result of positivistic influences which attempt to find psycho-social reasons for non-conformity. He articulates that it is flawed to assume delinquent subcultures are zealously embraced by deviants, furthermore, he points out that this intermittent interaction with subterranean values is normal because these values are replicated many times throughout society, albeit most times in controlled environments. He argues that traditional positivistic models of deviance, depict an ââ¬Å"antagonistic disjunction between deviant or subterranean values of larger societyâ⬠(Taylor et al: 1973) which is simply not true. Instead he argues that dev iants use techniques of neutralization as excuses for committing delinquent acts. Matza identified five techniques of neutralization employed by deviants to rationalize their non-conformity: (1) Denial of responsibility , wherein, the offender deflects blame with language such as ââ¬Å"it was not my faultâ⬠or ââ¬Å"it wasnââ¬â¢t really me who did itâ⬠. The deviant attributes their actions to the flaws of the wider substructure or environment. (2) Denial of injury, where the delinquent defends their actions on the grounds that it did not cause harm to anyone and substitutes moralistic condemnation on their actions with more favorable terminologies. For example, vandalism would be seen as ââ¬Å"just mischiefâ⬠. (3) Denial of a victim, where they place the victim as the offender in language such as ââ¬Å"they had it comingâ⬠or ââ¬Å"it didnââ¬â¢t affect themâ⬠. (4) Appeal to higher loyalties, where the delinquent places himself as torn between two groups with a need to commit the act in the interest of one group. A typical exampl e can be found with foreign national women who do transnational drug couriering, who mostly say they do it because of the economic needs of their children. (5) Condemnation of the condemners, where the offender deflects focus from their actions to chastise the motives of those who condemn the offending act. Those who condemn are usually classified by the deviant as hypocrites. Matzaââ¬â¢s (1964) Drift Theory attempts to situate the deviant in a less deterministic space than positivistic influenced theories allow. He suggested that persistent delinquent behaviour can be explained by a convergence of subterranean values and formal ones, in the absence of stabilizing forces which reinforce the more moralistic formal values. The slow movement from formal and introspective values to more permanent subterranean characteristics is called a ââ¬Å"driftâ⬠. In their period of drift, Matza contends that delinquents utilise the neutralizing techniques previously discussed, to weaken societyââ¬â¢s grasp on their value system. He is however, not without his critics, who point out that Matza underplay offending behaviour and neglects to use his theory as a lens for more violent forms of delinquency (Newburn: 2007). Matzaââ¬â¢s reasoning presents a shift from traditional subcultural theory which is more deterministic in its labelling and examination of deviants. Subculture theory contends that there are dominant cultures and deviant subcultures and they situate the deviant within the latter, because of their non-conformity. Subcultural theory romanticize the dominant culture as always existing within a positive moral space. It sees delinquency as a complete opposition to mainstream values and culture. Matza, on the other hand, advocates that delinquents do place value on mainstream cultures, but may refrain from displaying or voicing such views because they fear rejection from peers. He contends that subterranean values exist alongside those of the so-called dominant culture. This argument was partly sanctioned by Wolfgang and Ferracuti (1967) who proffered the example of the male who is compelled to violence to defend the honour of his mother, wife or children. While, this male is predispose d to accepting the dominant culture, his naturalistic tendency to defend in such situations, point to the co-existence of subterranean, even within mainstream cultures. References Matza, D. (1969) Becoming Deviant. New Jersey: Prentice Hall. Matza, D. (1964) Delinquency and Drift. New York: John Wiley and Sons. Matza, D., Sykes, G. (1961) Juvenile Delinquency and Subterranean Values. American Sociological Review Vol. 26, 713-719. Newburn, T. (2007) Criminology. Cullompton: Willan. Sykes, G., Matza, D. (1957) Techniques of Neutralization: A Theory of Delinquency. American Sociological Review, Vol. 22, 664-670. Taylor, I., Walton, P. Young, J. (1973) The New Criminology: For a Social Theory of Deviance. London: Routledge. Wolfgang, M., Ferracuti, F. (1967) The Subculture of Violence. London: Travistock Publishers. Young, J. (1974) New Directions in Subcultural Theory. In, John Rex (ed) Approaches to Sociology: An Introduction to Major Trends in British Sociology. London: RKP. 1
The Theoretical Framework For The Translation English Language Essay
The Theoretical Framework For The Translation English Language Essay The commentary will be divided into three sections. The first section will introduce the source text, establish the theoretical framework for the translation, define the translation brief and carry out a comparison of the functions of source and target texts. The next section will focus on defining and analyzing the strategies implemented in the translation by providing examples from within the translation. The final section will be a conclusion of the preceding sections. Source Text The source text is an article titled Xin, Da, Ya: On Yan Fus Translation Theories and was written in Chinese by Professor Wong Wang-Chi of the Chinese University of Hong Kong. The article was first published in the Journal of Translation Studies by the department of translation at the Chinese University of Hong Kong in 1997. Later it was published collection of works by author Wong in a book titled a Study of 20th Century Chinese Translation studies:Re-interpretation of xin, da and ya, by Shanghai Orient Press in 1999. The article contributes to the continuous academic debate among Chinese translation scholars on Yan Fus translation theory; xin, da and ya. Wong attempts to provide clearer interpretation of Yan Fus translation theory which had previously received much criticism claiming that it was flawed, inappropriate and contradictory. Due to the nature of text, it inevitably contains a large amount of theory-based content. The article was written with regard to Yan Fus translation preface of Tian Yan Lun, a translation of Huxleys Evolution and Ethics (1893). In this preface Yan Fu introduced his translation theory and it is therefore for this reason that Wongs piece contains large number quotations from Yan Fus preface; a preface which was written in classical Chinese prose in 1898, five years after the original was released. The fact that Yan Fus original translation was written in classical Chinese prose and obviously was published in the 19th century means that the way it is interpreted since then has been in constant debate. The combination of theory with both classical Chinese prose and modern Chinese means the task of translation was complex. The function of the original is to provide Chinese translation and literature fields with a fresh outlook on Yan Fus translation theory in response to previous criticism. It aims to change the critical way in which many scholars have looked upon this theory by allowing the reader to see Yan Fus theory in a different light. Deep down Wongs motives are clearly to defend Yan Fu and put right those previously who have misunderstood Yan Fus theory and then gone on to misrepresent Yan Fu in the field of translation studies. The target audience of the source text are Wongs fellow translation studies scholars and those students who are studying translation studies at least at undergraduate level. This is due to the heavy reliance on examples in classical Chinese prose throughout the text and the style of the authors writing. The text possesses a corrective and educative nature. Theoretical Framework A Brief Background A Functionalist Approach The theoretical framework chosen for this translation is a functionalist approach. The functionalist approach was first suggested by Kathrina Reiss in 1971 (2000:92), it developed further in the 1970s and 80s in Germany and was focal to the shift from predominantly linguistic and rather formal translation theories to a more functionally and socioculturally orientated concept of translation (Schaffner 1998:235). It was a shift that Gentzler described as one of the two most important theoretical developments in translation studies over the past two decades (2001:70). This aproach notably has been developed by a number of scholars in german language countries, including Kathrina Reiss, Hans Vermeer, Mary Snell-Hornby, Christiane Nord and Justa Holz-Manttari (2001:69). The functionalist approach not only allows for greater emphasis to be placed on the target text, but also provides a framework to evaluate better the role of the translator, something that previous theories failed to accom modate. The functionalist approach consists of a number of fundamental principles; All strategies are determined by the function of the translation. The function is defined by the commissioner through the translation brief. The function of the translation need not be identical to that of the original. A translation that achieves its intended purpose is to be declared as functional. (cf. Nord 2006) Functionalist scholars believe that translation should always strive to achieve optimal solutions within actual conditions (Gentzler 2001:70-71). However, importantly functionalist advocates admit there is no such thing as a perfect translation. Controversially the functionalist approach can be criticized as being too vague and not being extensive enough, Despite the plausible flaws in the approach, it is still recognized for decisively brought about the breaking of the two thousand year old chain of theory resolving around the faithful vs. free axis (Gentzler 2001:71). The framework for this translation will focus on Reiss and Vermeers Skopos theory (1984), a theory that has been established within the parameters of the functionalist approach. Skopos theory The was Skopos theory was established by Reiss and Vermeer in 1984. The theory is based around the skopos or the function, purpose or aim of a translation (Vermeer 1989:221). The main components of the theory are the overall aim (skopos), the purpose set in order to achieve the aim, the intention behind the aim and the eventual function of the target language text in terms of its readership. This means that any form of translation strategy implemented will be determined these four components of the skopos theory which in turn from the purpose that the translation will later go on to serve. Functionalists advocate that translation like any other activity in that behavior is determined by its intent, in other words, the end justifies the means (Nord 1997:29). The skopos theory provides the translator with the means to justify their decision making. According to Vermeer, every text has a given goal, function or intention and that any text can adopt a different function when applied in d ifferent circumstances with a different audience (1989:227). Therefore the translation is no longer classified as loyal or disloyal, but measured in terms of how consistent translation is in relation to the purpose and intention of the target text, which are defined from the viewpoint of the receiver. An important aspect of the skopos theory is that the source and target texts must be viewed separately to allow the theory to function. Reiss and Vermeer state that every text is an offer of information and indicating that the source and target text a two separate entities (House 1997:16). The translator is simply offering certain information from the source text in accordance with the skopos specified by the commissioner (Reiss and Vermeer 1991:76) By distinguishing clearly between the source and target texts it enables the a kind of translation to be carried out that does not place the source text at its realm. In other words, the text can take on a new function which can be viewed as an extension of the original, even though it might involve changing the function altogether, as Nord states written texts can exist outside their original situation (1991/2005:8). This means again means that the function target text it not restricted by the original, but most importantly is pragmatica lly defined by the purpose of the intercultural transfer (1991/2005:11). One of the most significant aspects the Skopos theory is its approach to equivalence and adequacy. According to Reiss and Vermeer, equivalence can defined as an identical communicative function shared across both source and target texts (House 1997:12) and adequacy can be defined as being the relationship between the source and translation where no functional match is obtained and the skopos of the translation has been attended to (1997:12). At the same time, the skopos remains more important than any form of equivalence. In translating between Chinese and English, two contrasting cultures, it is pivotal that we highlight the fundamental principle that just in the same way that source text is bound to or embedded within the source culture, the target text should also be orientated towards the target culture (Vermeer 1989:222-223). Following on from the initial establishment of the skopos theory by Reiss and Vermeer, Chrisiane Nord also contributes to the functionalist approach. Nord modifies the previous work on skopos theory by attempting to rebalance the excessively target text orientated skopos theory, claiming the priority of the target text purpose does not mean that the source text is irrelevant, as it sometimes assumed (1997:62). Moreover, she points out that the source text provides the offer of information that forms the starting point for the offer of information formulated in the target text (1997:62). Nord extends on the skopos theory by providing a model of source text analysis that Reiss and Vermeer had failed to cover, which in turn makes for a more comprehensive theory, a theory which is used as a framework for this translation. It is also important to recognize as Nord concludes that optimum circumstances for carrying out translation is when intention and function would be analogous or even identical (1997:28). In the case of this translation the intentions certainly are analogous, which signifies this theory is appropriate for this translation. Other Relevant Approaches Text Typology This model of translation was based on Bulhers typology. Reiss outlined her three text types: informative, expressive and operative. This model of translation is focuses on the functional relationship between source and target texts. It fundamentally involves the categorization of texts into either on of the three categories mentioned above(Reiss 1977), then dependent on which category the text falls under determines the translation strategies implemented by the translator. Translational Action This theory was introduced by Hola-Manttari, who defines translation as a complex action designed to achieve a particular process (Nord 1997:12-13). Hola-Manttari focuses on specific aspects of the translation process such as the translator, the receiver of the message, time, place and medium. This approach has been praised by Schaffer, who recognizes the versatility in accommodating all types of translation (1997:5). The theory considers highly the needs of the target text receiver. Although similar to the skopos theory it also bears the wrath of Nords criticism for neglecting the source text (1991:28). Nords Model of Text Analysis Nords model of text analysis consists of two main aspects; extratextual factors and intratextual factors. It gives a framework that allows both the source and potential target text to be analyzed. Nord divides translation problems into four categories; pragmatic, cultural, linguistic and text specific (1991:158-160). Hypothetical Translation Brief The translation brief is very influential in any translation, it is even more important in the functionalist approach. It gives both explicit and implicit information with regard to the intention, purpose and audience. It defines the conditions under which the translation is practiced. It is these conditions that influence the way in which the translator behaves. Munday states that it allows the translator to prioritize what information to include in the target text and to see where the source text and the target text may diverge (2001:82). This translation has been commissioned by Renditions, the leading international journal of Chinese literature in English language.à Based in Hong Kong, Renditions has striven to provide a unique yet rich variety of both classical and contemporary Chinese literature to the western world. It will be made commercially available in topical edition based on Chinese translation theory. The translation aims to present the latest standpoint on one of the most influential Chinese translation theories in translation studies history.à It will bring a more balanced, comprehensive understanding of Yan Fus translation theory among western translation scholars and students of translation.à The translation should ensure that those in the West are more sensitive to his theory.à Source and Target Text Function In order to effectively identify the strategies necessary to carry out the translation we must first establish the function of both the source and target texts. As it has been stated in the preceding paragraph the function of the source text is to outline the authors interpretation of Yan Fus translation theory; correcting those previous misunderstandings and at the same time defend Yan Fu. Therefore, in certain aspects the text is fullfilling an informative function in that it is sharing the view of Professor Wong Kwok-Pung, but furthermore the text has a operational function in that it is arguing for the defense of Yan Fus translation theory and is attempting to convince its audience that Yan Fu has been misrepresented. It has then become apparent that he source text possesses a combination of two functions. It is important to point out that the audience for this text is very niche as it is an scholarly and theoretical text which contains classical Chinese prose even those with a u niversity education will not necessarily be able to comprehend. With regard to the function of the target text, the function is similar to that of the source text. The key difference is that it takes on more of an educative function. It intends to educate western scholars of translation through increasing their sensitivity to the on going Yan Fu debate among Chinese translation scholars. Consequently, the target text is content focused, therefore the offer of information must be accurate in relation to the offer of information in the source text (Nord :80). In order to ensure that the translator is able to effectively transfer this information accurately, it is recommended that a literal translation strategy is used providing it can reach a level of naturalness that guarantees clarity and the presentation of the ideas and understandings of a fairly complex translation theory. This important as presently there exists a diversity among the understandings of the main concepts that form the basis of the theory. At this moment there is a key differenc e between the source and target texts; the source text audience is limited by both style of writing (classical Chinese) and the actual contents. On the other hand, the target will be restricted only by its content and not by the writing style as it will be mainly plain English. Therefore it audience will be extended by a more reader friendly text. The target text is aiming to turn a complex source text into a target text that is much clearer Strategies Used I n this section the strategies used by the translator will be discussed. A functionalist approach, in particular the skopos theory will determine these strategies which applied in this translation. It has also been recognized that the text is both informative and operational. Therefore, a balance must be found between being highly content focused in which no loss of information can be accepted, but also ensure the function of text is achieved, the translator must render the text in so that it is readable and conforms to the target text language conventions. Terminology Research Dictionaries, glossaries and parallel texts provide a resource that allows vital terminology research. Dictionaries are a tool used by translators across the world. In this translation a number of dictionaries have been referenced; bilingual and monolingual both modern and classic Chinese. Bilingual dictionaries provide a comprehensive range of terms including examples in a number of contexts. Despite that, there are instances with certain terminology when the bilingual dictionary does not suffice. A monolingual dictionary is used in instances when the incompleteness and inconsistency of the bilingual dictionary mean that terminology cannot be referenced. A specialized ancient chinese dictionary was required in this translation as the source text contains substantial amounts of classical Chinese prose. Dictionaries used Due to the difficulty in dealing with sections of classical Chinese prose within the source text, It was unavoidable that the translator depend on the assistance of a specialists outside of the field of translation. Nord (1991:158-160) describes this as being a text-specific problem, which is one of the four translation problems, as the source was written by a specialist. Although the fact that area of specialization in the source text is translation, but the fact that it is a technical text (1991:158-160) does still prove to be a problem. In terms of this translation, I sought the cooperation of a post graduate student from the University of Warwick who possessed an excellent knowledge of classical Chinese prose. He was able to help with difficulties in terminology and provide an evaluated opinion on the translated version of certain terms. Omission Omission is a strategy that is employed in instances when information is redundant and is non-beneficial to the function of the translation or the target reader. All forms of information must be able to make sense in the culture in which they exist. For example, the footnotes in the source text give reference to several Chinese authors and their work, all of which is in Chinese. I do not believe that supplying a translated version of these footnotes will provide any real support to the purpose of the text. Therefore, I have omitted all four of the footnotes which were present in the original. It is appreciated that some people believe the footnotes should be preserved in the translation and further explanatory information should accompany them. Despite this the decision to omit was made as the information was simply not significant enough to the target reader. Addition It is natural that the background knowledge of the source text audience and the target text audience may differ.à This means that the translator at times must employ strategies to either omit redundant or irrelevant information and also provide more information to supplement the the text in order to counteract the in balance in background knowledge, and in turn enable the target text reader to comprehend. There are a number instances in which historical and culture points are referred to within the source text.à These points are crucial in the explanation of Wongs standpoint and the understanding of Yan Fus theory.à By providing supplementary information regarding those theoretical terms, historical and cultural references in the translation it ensures the English readers are able to understand.à In particular with the terms xin, da and ya which are used throughout the text.à It is very important to add supplementary explanations.à If these items are not made clear in the initial stages of the translation then they will lead to the reader being distracted which is detrimental to the development of the text. Literal translation Literal translation involves following closely the structure, form and lexical meanings of the source text. It is based converting text constructions into their target text equivalents. By translating each lexical word means they are often out of context in target text form. It allows for accuracy in the transfer of information that explains why many people have misunderstood Yan Fus ideas. The main issue with literal translation is that those implicit and contextual meanings are neglected. This could potentially be damaging to the effective transfer of information. Example Source Text: à §Ã¢â¬ à ±Ã ¤Ã ºÃ
½Ã ¥Ã
âà ¨Ã ¨Ã ¯Ã ´Ã ¥Ã ®Ã
âà ¨Ã ¿Ã¢â ¢Ã ¦Ã à ·Ã §Ã
¡Ã¢â¬Å¾Ã ¤Ã ¸Ã¢â ¬Ã ¥Ã à ¥Ã ¨Ã ¯Ã à ¼Ã
âà ¤Ã ¸Ã ¥Ã ¥Ã ¤Ã à ¨Ã¢â¬ ¡Ã ªÃ ¥Ã ·Ã ±Ã ¥Ã ¹Ã ¶Ã ¦Ã ²Ã ¡Ã ¦Ã
ââ⬠°Ã ©Ã ©Ã ¬Ã ¤Ã ¸Ã
à ¤Ã ¸Ã ºÃ ¨Ã ¿Ã¢â ¢Ã ¤Ã ¸Ã¢â¬ °Ã ¤Ã ¸Ã ªÃ ¨Ã ¯Ã à ¤Ã ¸Ã¢â¬ ¹Ã ¥Ã ®Ã
¡Ã ¤Ã ¹Ã¢â¬ °Ã ¦Ãâ -à ¤Ã ½Ã
âà ¨Ã ¯Ã ¦Ã §Ã »Ã¢â¬ à §Ã
¡Ã¢â¬Å¾Ã ¨Ã £Ã ©Ã¢â¬ ¡Ã
à ¼Ã
âà §Ã »Ã¢â¬Å"à ¦Ã
¾Ã
âà ¥Ã ¼Ã¢â¬ ¢Ã ¦Ã à ¥Ã ¤Ã ºÃ¢â¬ à ¤Ã ¸Ã à ¥Ã °Ã¢â¬Ëà ¨Ã¢â¬ ¡Ã¢â¬ à §Ã
âÃ
âà ¥Ã Ã
à ¦Ã ·Ã ·Ã ¤Ã ¹Ã ±Ã £Ã¢â ¬Ã¢â¬Å¡ Target Text: Due to the fact that Yan Fu himself did neither define nor explain in detail these three characters immediately after proclaiming them, as a result it led to much subjective speculation and confusion. In the example above a literal translation strategy has been implemented. The original forms and meanings have been preserved, or at least to some extent. In the first example, due to the fact that there is an equivalent available in the target text means the translation is straightforward. However, in the second example, to simply render the text in accordance with the source text would result in unnaturalness. As a result the it has been altered to conform with the target text norms. As there is an evident inter-lingual difference between Chinese and English, there are instances in which it is not possible to translate literary. An attempt at literal translation will result in unnaturalness in the target language text. In my translation a number of pragmatic strategies have been employed, all of which promote naturalness and readability in the target text. Admittedly, accuracy may be sacrificed in order to ensure the target text audience are able understand and fully engage with the target text. There are a few examples below; Example 1.01 Source Text: à ¥Ã¢â¬ °Ã ²Ã ¨Ã £Ã¢â¬Å¡Ã §Ã
¡Ã¢â¬Å¾Ã ¦Ã¢â¬ °Ã¢â¬ ¹Ã ¦Ã ³Ã¢â¬ ¢ Literal Translation: Carving up technique Target Text: Misrepresentation Potential Alternative: Quote of context; garble his statement Example 1.02 Source Text: GAP Literal Translation: Eliminate Target Text: Clear up In the two examples above illustrates a certain loss in meaning. The source text expresses more strongly in a way that becomes unnatural in the target text. In the target text example 1.01 it shows a two version of translation. The translator had to decide not to use the potential alternative because to a certain extent it seemed too toned down and neutral to truly represent the source text. The translator opted to use misrepresentation as it is able to represent at least to some extent the strong connotation of the original. It is inevitable that strong connotation in the original is to be sacrificed in order to achieve naturalness in the target text. The next example (1.02) is a connotation similar to the previous example, but it was not possible to find an equivalent that possessed the same strong connotation as in the target text. The translator is left with no choice but sacrifice the connotation for a weaker, more natural target text equivalent. This kind of adaptation guarante es naturalness. Example 1.03 Source Text: à ©Ã â⬠à §Ã â⬠à ¦Ãâ à Literal Translation: Following a logical chain of thought Target Text: Reasonably Potential Alternative: Naturally Example 1.04 Source Text: à §Ã ¼ÃÅ"à ¦Ã
âà ¨Ã ¦Ã ±Ã¢â¬Å¡Ã ©Ã ±Ã ¼ Literal Translation: climbing a tree to seek a fish. Target Text: Fruitless approach Potential Alternative: climbing a tree to seek a fish (a fruitless approach) Although the two examples above (1.03 and 1.04) both can be translated literally, however, they seem to be too long-winded. The translation must conform to the norms of the target language. It is important to avoid any unnecessary unnaturalness that may be detrimental to the development of the target text. As the authors intention is to defend Yan Fus theory, it is crucial that messages and meanings are transferred into the target text effectively. Example 1.05 illustrates an example where a target version that strongly represents the meaning of the source is rejected due to its length and unnaturalness. Source Text: à ¤Ã ¿Ã ®Ã ¨Ã ¾Ã
¾Ã §Ã «Ã¢â¬ ¹Ã ¨Ã ¯Ã
¡ Rejected translation: The use of certain methods specifically in accordance with the subject of the literary piece allows for enhanced cultural expression, faithfully expressing the real ideas and emotions of the original Target Text: An authors writing allows for enhanced expression that should sincerely reflect his thoughts and emotions In-text reference As the name suggests, it is the providing of extra information within the text itself. It is a strategy used to explain a term that is alien to the readership such as Kuomintang (Chinese Nationalist Party) or simply assist them in comprehending the text. In the translation this strategy was not used often as it confuses the reader, especially in theoretical based text. Syntactical Convention The syntactic structure of Chinese and English are different. In terms of this translation, this means that alterations to the sequencing elements of the source text so that it reads naturally in the target language. An example of the changes that need to be made is shown below; Source Text: à ¥Ã ®Ã
¾Ã ¥Ãâ â⠢à §Ã ²Ã ¾Ã §Ã â⬠à ¥Ã ¾Ã ®Ã ¨Ã ¨Ã¢â ¬Ã ¼Ã
âà §Ã¢â¬ à ¨Ã ¦Ã ±Ã¢â¬ °Ã ¤Ã »Ã ¥Ã ¥Ã¢â¬ °Ã à ¥Ã -à ¦Ã ³Ã¢â¬ ¢Ã £Ã¢â ¬Ã à ¥Ã à ¥Ã ¦Ã ³Ã¢â¬ ¢Ã ¼Ã
âà ¥Ãâ â⠢à ¤Ã ¸Ã ºÃ ¨Ã ¾Ã ¾Ã ¦ÃÅ"ââ¬Å"à ¼Ã¢â¬ ºÃ §Ã¢â¬ à ¨Ã ¨Ã ¿Ã¢â¬Ëà ¤Ã ¸-à ¥Ãâ à ©Ã ¤Ã ¿-à ¦-â⬠¡Ã ¥Ã -à ¼Ã
âà ¥Ãâ â⠢à ¦Ã ±Ã¢â¬Å¡Ã ¨Ã ¾Ã ¾Ã ©Ã
¡Ã ¾Ã £Ã¢â ¬Ã¢â¬Å¡ Literal Transaltion: The fact is that with original texts which contain abstruse contents and are written in the terse and allusive language, to use the lexicon and sentence structure of pre-Han Dynasty proves better in expressing the original texts. Target Text: The fact is that the lexicon and sentence structures of pre-Han Dynasty prose prove to better express original texts which contain abstruse contents and are written in the terse and allusive language. The underlined part of each example highlights the change in structure. The text must function as an informative or educative and present an argument, in order to achieve this, the above adaptation has been made to emphasize readability. The next example below demonstrates the problems with complex sentence structures. To allow the reader to understand the target text modification is inevitable. Source Text: à ¨Ã¢â¬ ¡Ã ªÃ §Ã¢â¬Å¾Ã ¶Ã ¼Ã
âà ¤Ã ¸Ã ¥Ã ¥Ã ¤Ã à ¨Ã ¦Ã à ¦Ã ±Ã¢â¬Å¡Ã §Ã¢â¬ à ¨Ã ¦Ã ±Ã¢â¬ °Ã ¤Ã »Ã ¥Ã ¥Ã¢â¬ °Ã à ¥Ã -à ¦Ã ³Ã¢â¬ ¢Ã ¼Ã
âà ¥Ã à ¥Ã ¦Ã ³Ã¢â¬ ¢Ã ¦Ã à ¥Ã ¤Ã ½Ã
âà §Ã ¿Ã »Ã ¨Ã ¯Ã¢â¬Ëà ¼Ã
âà ¤Ã ¸Ã¢â¬ à ¨Ã ®Ã ¤Ã ¤Ã ¸Ã ºÃ ¥Ã à ¯Ã ¤Ã »Ã ¥Ã ¥Ã Ã
¡Ã ¥Ãâ à °Ã ¨Ã ¾Ã ¾Ã ¦ÃÅ"ââ¬Å"à §Ã
¡Ã¢â¬Å¾Ã ¦Ã¢â¬ ¢Ãâ à ¦Ã
¾Ã
âà ¼Ã
âà ¤Ã »Ã
à ¥Ã ¤Ã ©Ã §Ã
ââ⬠¹Ã ¦Ã à ¥Ã ¥Ã ¾Ãâ à ¤Ã ¸Ã à ¥Ã à ¯Ã ¦Ã¢â ¬Ã à ¨Ã ®Ã ®Ã ¼Ã
âà ¤Ã ½Ã¢â¬ à ¥Ã ¦Ã¢â¬Å¡Ã ¦Ã
¾Ã
âà ¦Ãâ ââ¬Ëà ¤Ã »Ã ¬Ã ¨Ãâà ½Ã ¤Ã »Ã
½Ã ¥Ã
½Ã¢â¬ à ¥Ã à ²Ã §Ã
¡Ã¢â¬Å¾Ã ¨Ã¢â¬â¢Ã ¥Ã ºÃ ¦Ã ¥Ã
½Ã »Ã §Ã
ââ⬠¹Ã ¨Ã ¿Ã¢â ¢Ã ¤Ã ¸Ã ªÃ ©-à ®Ã ©Ã ¢ÃÅ"à ¼Ã
âà ¤Ã ¾Ã ¿Ã ¤Ã ¸Ã à ¤Ã ¼Ã
¡Ã ¨Ã¢â¬ °Ã ¥Ã ¾-à ¦Ã
ââ⬠°Ã ¤Ã »Ã¢â ¬Ã ¤Ã ¹Ãâ à ¤Ã ¸Ã à ¥Ã ¦Ã ¥Ã ¤Ã ¹Ã¢â¬ ¹Ã ¥Ã ¤Ã¢â¬Å¾Ã ¤Ã ºÃ¢â¬ à £Ã¢â ¬Ã¢â¬Å¡ Literal Translation: Naturally, Yan Fus demands of using lexicon and sentence structure of pre-Han Dynasty prose in carrying out translation, furthermore the belief that it can achieve da, today it seems unthinkable, but if we look at this problem from a historical point of view then we wouldnt feel that there was any inappropriateness at all. Target Text: Naturally, today when we look back on Yan Fus belief of using lexicon and sentence structure of pre-Han Dynasty prose to achieving da, it seems to be unimaginable. However, if we look at this problem from a historical point of view then we wouldnt feel that there was any inappropriateness at all. The lengthy sentence in the example above has not only been divided into two separate units or sentences, but also the order of the units have been rearranged for it to make sense. Elsewhere, in Chinese the subjects are often unexpressed and the object can also occasionally be omitted. In particular, these instances occur more frequently in classical Chinese. It is left to the reader to determine the subject and object in any given sentence which can prove ambiguous. When rendering the text it is important the object or subject is inserted into the translated text to allow the reader to understand. This is shown in example 1.07 where the object is inserted in square brackets to ensure the reader is not confused. The channels that communicate the message of the original should be kept clear and concise. Alterations The source does not only contain a number of paragraphs from Yan Fus original translation preface, the author also quotes on a number of occasions throughout his text. This means the task of translation becomes extremely difficult because the context changes slightly. The initial issue is that it is was not possible to translate the sections of classical Chinese literally, furthermore, as it was very important to make clear the original meanings in these sections as Wong bases his essay on them, the translation strategy adopted was loyal to the meanings and had to presented be clear, concise and natural in the target language. It is for this reason that literal translation was not possible. However, the problem arose when these translations had to fit into Wongs main texts that were written in mainly in modern Chinese. Example 1.05 demonstrates that in the original classical Chinese it does contain the word meaning, but it is left out because it is not necessary in the context of the whole passage. As Wong quotes this line in a separate instance the meaning is then required. In this instance the translator must use an in-text reference and not change the structure of the quotation in order to remain consistent. If a translation shows inconsistency then the reader will be confused. Example 1.05 Source Text: à ¦Ã¢â¬Å¾Ã à ¤Ã ¹Ã¢â¬ °Ã ¥Ãâ â⠢à ¤Ã ¸Ã à ¥Ã¢â ¬Ã à ¦Ã
âà ¬Ã ¦-â⬠¡ Translated Passage of Classical Chinese: provided that the translation does not contradict of the original Quotation from the Passage in Main Text: provided that the translation does not contradict [the meaning] of the original) Footnotes Footnotes are used to provide additional information that is necessary to further explain certain terms or concepts in the text. They are usually employed when the supplementary information needed is too long to provide a parenthetical reference. It must be noted that footnotes should be used minimally to avoid distracting the reader in a way which will negatively influence the development of the text. As Baker states, unnecessary addition of information will only lower the readability of the text (1992:40). This translation uses footnotes to enable the reader to understand the source text. In other words they ensure the reader maintains connected with the text. For example to present an alien term without giving a supplementary explanation to the reader leads them to be unable to maintain their connection with the text. In this text there are instances when footnotes are employed to make the target text clearer in areas in which the author of the source text has failed, example on p age XX of the translation the translator uses footnotes to explain the term expression of intention which is one of the main elements of Yan Fus theory. The original author has not made much effort to make the chunks of classical Chinese prose more comprehendible to someone who does not understand this form of ancient Chinese. By doing this the author expresses that he wishes his text to function only among a very niche audience, I mean Wong could have provided a modern Chinese version of those sections. In the translation, the use of clear, plain English eradicates this potential restriction on its audience. The translated text intends to be accessible to all those who have interest in or understanding of the theoretical content of the original. Therefore, in a way the translation extends the influence of the original. In addition footnotes are used to counteract the lack of shared background knowledge between the source and target audience. The strategy shown below is an example of contextual amplification in which items, which source readers take for granted and that target readers do not understand, are explained. Example 1 On Page XX an explanation of the Tong
Saturday, July 20, 2019
How to Write a Synthesis Essay :: Synthesis Essays, Argumentative Essays
A synthesis is a written discussion that draws on one or more sources. It follows that your ability to write syntheses depends on your ability to infer relationships among sources - essays, articles, fiction, and also nonwritten sources, such as lectures, interviews, observations. This process is nothing new for you, since you infer relationships all the time - say, between something you've read in the newspaper and something you've seen for yourself, or between the teaching styles of your favorite and least favorite instructors. In fact, if you've written research papers, you've already written syntheses. In an academic synthesis, you make explicit the relationships that you have inferred among separate sources. The skills you've already been practicing in this course will be vital in writing syntheses. Clearly, before you're in a position to draw relationships between two or more sources, you must understand what those sources say; in other words, you must be able to summarize these sources. It will frequently be helpful for your readers if you provide at least partial summaries of sources in your synthesis essays. At the same time, you must go beyond summary to make judgments - judgments based, of course, on your critical reading of your sources - as you have practiced in your reading responses and in class discussions. You should already have drawn some conclusions about the quality and validity of these sources; and you should know how much you agree or disagree with the points made in your sources and the reasons for your agreement or disagreement. Further, you must go beyond the critique of individual sources to determine the relationship among them. Is the information in source B, for example, an extended illustration of the generalizations in source A? Would it be useful to compare and contrast source C with source B? Having read and considered sources A, B, and C, can you infer something else - D (not a source, but your own idea)? Because a synthesis is based on two or more sources, you will need to be selective when choosing information from each. It would be neither possible nor desirable, for instance, to discuss in a ten-page paper on the battle of Wounded Knee every point that the authors of two books make about their subject. What you as a writer must do is select the ideas and information from each source that best allow you to achieve your purpose. Your purpose in reading source materials and then in drawing upon them to write your own material is often reflected in the wording of an assignment.
Friday, July 19, 2019
The Interplay between Emotion and Reason Essay -- Psychology Essays
The Interplay between Emotion and Reason "And this is of course the difficult job, is it not: to move the spirit from it's nowhere pedestal to a somewhere place, while preserving its dignity and importance." I cry. There is pressure behind my eyes, my skin turns blotchy and my lips tremble, and mucus clogs my airways, making it difficult to breath. I hate crying in front of others: not because I want to hide how upset I am, but because the second that most people perceive my emotional state as fragile, they assume my reasoning and mental functions are also not sound. The outward expression of an inward instability is something we save for those who we know and trust best. They do not view our emotionality as a weakness, they already know us to be strong. Crying is represented in our culture as a lack of control. When upset, the "ideal" is to keep a cool head (and a poker face), not allowing emotions to enter into the decision making process. However, I submit that without our emotional base, rationality would have no reason or foundation upon which to operate. A multitude of opinions are found on the subject: are emotions more a function of the heart or of the head? According to Antonio Damasio (1), emotions and feelings are an integral part of all thought; yet we as humans spend much of our time attempting to disregard and hide them. In the view of source (2), experience is the result of integration of cognition and feelings. In either view, it remains indisputable that emotions are not what we typically make them out to be: the unwanted step-sister of our cultural sweetheart reason. Reason in our culture denotes intelligence, cognition, and control. Emotions seems such a "scary" concept to our collective m... ...tenderness, and luster gone. Is this also reflective of some human insecurity? Not until we can bridge the illusioned gap between our emotions and our cognition can we understand fully the relationship between our brain and our behavior. References 1) A.R. Damasio, Descartes' Error, 1994 2) Thinking, Emotions, and the Brain http://www.drweitz.com/scientific/brain.htm 3) From Neurobiology to Psychopathology: Integrating Cognition and Emotion, on the NIMH website http://www.nimh.nih.gov/diva/neuropsych.cfm 4) Laughing out Loud to Good Health. http://library.thinkquest.org/25500/index2.htm?tqskip1=1&tqtime=0416 5) William Shakespeare (1564ââ¬â1616). The Oxford Shakespeare. 1914. , on the bartleby website. http://www.bartleby.com/70/2041.html 6 Theories of Emotion--Understanding our own Emotional Experience. http://www.bartleby.com/70/2041.html
Black Women in Art Essay -- essays research papers fc
Black Women in Art Historically and currently African American women use art as a way to express themselves, their emotions and as an act of resistance. In this paper, I will discuss the various ways two very influential artists, Laurie Cooper and Lorna Simpson, use imagery to uncover and forefront the various forms of oppression that affect their lives as African American women. Since the late 1970s, African American art, as a form of self expression, explores issues which concern African peoples worldwide. During this time period, African American artists use symbols which represent the struggles, despair, hopes and dreams of a people striving to debunk prominent stereotypes and dismantle the intersecting oppressions of race, class and gender. Despite the long history of African American art, many black artists in contemporary society still have a difficult time getting their art viewed or accepted by the masses. Society, in general, tends to look at African art as ethnic, trivial, simple, folk art, perhaps even collectable, but not worthy of true in-depth exploration of fine art accreditation. However, Laurie Cooper and Lorna Simpson disrupt these perceptions in their art. Lorna Simpson, a photographer, was born in New York during the sixties. Still residing there today, she remains active in the art world. Simpson brings much attention to a cause near and dear to her, the ââ¬Å"situation of black women in society.â⬠The ambiguity in her photographs allows the viewer to evaluate the meaning of her work and to draw their own conclusion with her spirit in mind. An excellent example of this is in her piece Counting(1991). The Albright-Knox Art Gallery helps interpret the piece: Lorna Simpsonââ¬â¢s work, Counting, contains three images: a fragment of a womanââ¬â¢s body, a small brick hut, and a group of braids. The figure is anonymous and wears a white shift, Simpsonââ¬â¢s preferred costume for her models. She likes the simplicity; she believes that it indicates what she terms "femaleness," without bringing up issues of fashion; and she also likes the fact that there are many possible interpretations for such an outfit. The times to the right of the figure might indicate work shifts, but the schedules are unrealistic if considered closely. Other possibilities for what they might mean are open to viewer interpretation. The central image shows a smoke house in Sout... ...e, the work is not answer oriented. Itââ¬â¢s intentionally left open-ended. Thereââ¬â¢s not a resolution that just solves everything. This statement leaves the viewer free to form their own conclusion and remain open to various interpretations. Lorna Simpson and Laurie Cooper help to change the world for the better by addressing confrontational, silenced issues by opening the eyes of the world to all of the ââ¬Å"ismsâ⬠that plague society and gives us hope for the future. Both women subvert traditional imagery, physically and psychologically in prominent historic and current representations of African Americanââ¬â¢s historically and currently in American society. This subversion allows their artwork to escape the marginalization of African American art as seemingly ââ¬Å"ethnic folk artâ⬠and exposes their works as tools for social progression. Bibliography 1. 2. 3. 4. Jorge Arango. ââ¬Å"At Home with Lorna Simpson.â⬠Essence Magazine, 2002, p.172 5. Audre Lorde. ââ¬Å"Beyond the Marginsâ⬠Words of Fire, The New Press, 1995, p.287
Thursday, July 18, 2019
Family Honor
Family honor is romeo and juliet is represented by the constant attempts to preserve family pride from both houses. This defense and pride causes many deaths and deeper problems that are passed down from generation to generation. In the first scene of romeo and juliet, the montagues and capulets come across each other, and because of the deep rooted hatred they have for each other's fmilies, they taunt one another and begin to fight. This fight worsens the already tarnished relationship the two houses share. Tybalt, a capulet, holds a strong place in defending his family's honor. It is so strong that he even enjoys it. Like Tybalt, the Montegues are fueled by their hatred for one another. What they don't realize is that this hatred only challenges each other's family honor. Family honor is not always such a negative thing. This can similarly occur outside fiction as well. In my family, there has been little representation of family honor. For example, moving around at such a high rate, we have been unable to develop feuds with other families. There were bits of family honor in my life. At school I was against telling anyone details about what was going on in my home life in an attempt to protect and defend my family's honor. This often was unsuccessful. Though, the type of family honor show in my life differed from the family honor shown in Romeo and Juliet. All in all, there is a distinct representation of famly honor in Romeo and juliet. This honor can also be shown in real life. This completely depends on the family and what family honor means to them. For me, family honor is not a huge factor in my life. This does not mean I do not have family pride. I cannot relate much to romeo and juliet.
Wednesday, July 17, 2019
What Role Do Mobile Phones Play in Society?
1. What role do expeditious phones do in society? Discuss the limit of engine room on popular action relationships, neighborly movements and education. brisk phones impart a major impact on upstart society as they be to a greater extent and much hireful social to a faultls. In 2004, thither were approximately two billion fluid subscribers world-wide Arminen 2007. The majority of worldwide businesses exercising this technology to pop t in ally. actives curb change overd the authority commonwealth fancy up activities, meetings and social occasions, and generally the delegacy nation go about living e rattling daylight life. smooth phones increase contact with peers, so a psyche stop forever and a day know whats going on with those close to them. They help tidy sum conduct more efficiently, anywhere on the planet. vigorous phones bind developed multi-features they atomic number 18 more than just a phone and brook be used for direct textbook messages, taking photos, surfing the internet, playing music, victimisation a calculator, setting an alarm, playing games, sending email, checking the time, calendar, maps, GPS, banking, radio, businesss such as voice memos, and atomic number 18 capable of an astonish amount of functions and some fork over many more functions than a estimator, have the added premium of senior high portability.On the down look however mobile phones quite a little secern down personal barriers where a person can find it hard to have any personal time, or infix fully in their pitch environs without interruptions as the majority of people never turn off their phone, so thither is al bearings constant communion. Modern day society has formed a very strong reliance on mobile phones where most individual(a)s cannot leave stem without their mobiles and have developed a extremity to be constantly contacted. Overall mobiles have a very large influence on relationships. active phones play a wide role specifically in adolescences relationships.Mobile phone technology allows us to communicate with social groups in new ways, and to affirm those relationships, regard slight of distance. SMS connects individuals in a non invasive way so time and somatogenic location are no lifelong important boundaries to communication (Horstmanshof & Power, 2005) instead the suddenness of the message is more important exponent of uptake giving rise to yeasty code. Horstmanshof and Powers research looked at how the new communication was being interpreted up by what groups, and the rules, communication and social interaction of those groups.The results showed that SMS was mostly used to shorten close relationships. Mobile phones provide an easier way to communicate, and helps some shy adolescences become more social. Furthermore text message or SMS, help adolescences check each some other out (Cupples & Thompson 2010) without embarrassment of getting spurned by a potential partner. Mobile phones assist in taking out any awkwardness on the succeeding(prenominal) appointment or date by getting to know a curious or potential partner (Cupples & Thompson), by facilitating the asking of questions a person wouldnt normally ask face to face. contempt their many positives mobile phones can have a negative side. All the approachability leaves people with little personal uninterrupted. As Horstmanshof and Power describe its the like you are inviting the whole world into your space at any time the mobile is on. The substantially accessible, relatively cheap and individualised reputation of mobile phones has increased their popularity to the point where they have changed the way people interact at work as well as at home (Geser 2010). Mobile phones are increasingly breaking down the boundaries surrounded by work and home.Mobiles have changed the way individuals pull in decisions from individual to more consultative, the way people report emergencies, the social messages of status or connectedness we send to others who witness our calls, the way people participate in the beat with increasing interruptions, the way people hold open social obligations and the way people can change appointments at short notice, the way we can access greater amounts of information, and importantly, the change from a specific, location based communication system (landline) to an individual recipient.Geser suggests mobiles allow an individual to carry the cocoon of another household to where we are at present which whitethorn be a different fleck emotionally as well as physiologicly to our current location and we pauperism to skillfully maneuver between the two. This is oddly important in the work home boundaries. We need to make new decisions about when we are interrupted and how to deal with the present social or work situations (Geser) which whitethorn result in more egotism control as well as more social control like requesting people turn off their phones on ward meetings.Geser to a fault supports that with their great ease mobiles withal raise some concerns about people but especially children being less independent, and about mobile phone use contributing to fracturing social cohesion by means of subgroups potentially challenging the norm and the lesser social influence of more chunk networks to increasingly informal networks. Technology has evolved where a person can access almost anything on their mobile phone including the internet, so that information is very slowly accessible.Mobiles can help students do calculations through with(predicate) the use of a calculator or victimization specific programs on a computer such as the SPSS program Swinburne University uses for statistics. Encyclopedias are readily accessed online mostly for free which helps a person access the information they need at any time irrespective of library opening hours or physical location. Almost all information is in stock(predicate) at a click of a butt on. There is withal computer sponsor learning programs (Cradler et. l 2002) such as cogmed working shop training (a memory training used for individuals with short landmark memory difficulties) that can be accessed through the mobile. Individuals are also not contain to working on a produce if they live in regional part of the world as there is university and high schools based online and accessible through mobiles. except there are consequences of having to much easily accessible information.People become too dependent on often petty information and dont research as thoroughly. Skills, such as recite are often diminished as Microsoft Word corrects spelling mistakes and even helps with grammar. less(prenominal) effort is required in advanced day society where it can be argued people are fed information. It has also become easy to plagiarize (Snooks and Co, 2002) and facsimile other peoples work and pass it off as your own but also easily to be found out.ReferencesArminen , I, 2007, redirect examination Essay, Mobile Communication Society? , Mobile Communication Society? , v. 53, no. 1 University of Tampere viewed 19 march 2010 http//asj. sagepub. com Cogmed, 1999 Karolinska Institute, viewed 6 April 2010, http//www. cogmed. com/ Cupples, J Thompson, L, 2010, Heterotextuality and Digital Foreplay, Feminist Media Studies, v. 10, no. 1, pp. 1-17, Ebscohost viewed 19 contact 2010 http//www. informaworld. com/smpp/contentdb=allcontent=a919196107Geser, H, 2004, Towards a Sociological guess of the Mobile Phone, Sociology in Switzerland Sociology of the Mobile Phone, Google Scholar viewed 16 March 2010 http//socio. ch/mobile/t_geser1. pdf Horstmanshof, L, Power, MR, 2005, Mobile phones, SMS, and relationships, Humanities accessible Sciences papers, v. 32, no. 1, pp. 33-52, Bond University viewed 16 March 2010 http//epublications. bond. edu. au/hss_pubs/75/ Snooks and Co 2002, means manual for authors, editors and printers, 6th edn, John Wiley Sons , Milton, Qld. promulgated 2010
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)